Key West

Known for having adorable critters, like chickens and cats, that roam around the idyllic space, Blue Heaven is country chic al fresco fares at their finest. They’ve been around since 1992, and have gained quite a rave reputation among the Florida foodies.
It’s set in the historic Bahama Village, and the space is covered in canopies of tropical foliage that are decked out with whimsy. There’s often live music to complete the charming ambiance. The menu features American, Caribbean, and vegetarian cuisine, and each plate is expertly crafted with care.
Breakfast and lunch are first come first serve, but you may want to make a reservation if you’re hoping to go for dinner. The Caribbean BBQ Shrimp, Jamaican Jerk Chicken, and Island Plate are a few of the fan favorites. There’s a special Sunday breakfast menu, and it’s a lovely pick for a beautiful brunch in town. So if you are on the hunt for Sunday Brunch in Key West make sure to check out Blue Heaven.

Blue Heaven

This cozy cafe spot is located inside the high-end Marquesa Hotel in Old Town Key West and it focuses on creative New American eats. It’s a beloved institution of the area, it’s one of the local favorite restaurants, and tourists love it too. Some of the menu items feature grilled meats, fresh local seafood, seasonal produce, freshly baked bread, and desserts made daily. Inventive interpretations of classic cuisines are their claim to fame, with delicious dishes such as the Butter Poached Lobster and Crispy Pork Osso Buco.
Be sure to save room for something sweet here as well. The presentation is always picture perfect. There’s also a cozy bar for enjoying a few beverages or light bites. They have an extensive selection of fine wines from all over the world, as well as creative cocktails. Cafe Marquesa is the ideal dining destination for a fancy night out on the town in Key West.
Cafe Marquesa has a rather small dining room so it’s best to call ahead and make reservations.

Cafe Marquesa Key West

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen is an airy eatery that features picturesque waterfront panoramas overlooking the marina. The views are even better outside if you ask us, we really enjoy their outdoor dining area. The decor is modern and minimal and they focus on elevated coastal comfort foods. Each plate is thoughtful and created in a simple way that lets the amazing ingredients really speak for themselves.
As they say, what grows together goes together. For some of the freshest seafood in Key West, you can even bring your own fresh catch in for them to prepare after a day of angling out in the open Florida Keys seas. The Crab Beignets have become a famous bite here, and are definitely a must-try on a menu full of stand-out dishes, like the Grouper Gnudi and Mussels and Clams Cioppino Style.
Reservations are required to get a table here. Whether you go for breakfast, dinner, or simply a few cocktails to enjoy the view, Matt’s is a great place for contemporary cuisine in Key West.

Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

Bagatelle is set inside a historic building that was constructed way back in the 1800s. Today it’s home to some of the best food in Key West, seafood-focused, and American Caribbean style menu. Everything is locally and sustainably sourced.
The space itself is architecturally stunning, with giant wrap-around porches for that ideal Floridian alfresco feasting. It’s a beautiful spot for brunch any day of the week, and they even offer two happy hours per day. One is the breakfast hangover happy hour from 9 to 11:30 AM, and the other is the afternoon slot from 4 to 6 PM which offers $5 tasting plates and half off on cocktails.
A must-try is their signature dish the Lobster Mac and Cheese, it is a favorite staple here. They also have a great selection of wine, with something to pair perfectly with any plate. This local restaurant is located right on the famous Duval Street making it an easy restaurant to visit while exploring Key West.

Bagatella

Bagatelle

This Key West Cuban restaurant is a coveted icon within the community, drawing in crowds with a vibrant and rustic feel, live Salsa music, and authentic cuisine. They operate on a first come first serve basis only. It’s also family-owned and operated, and has been around since 1985.
They’re dedicated to celebrating the flavors of the Cuban-Conch heritage. They’re located in Mallory Square, a spot known for its sunset parties, so it’s a great way to partake in the festivities here while enjoying some tapas and classic tropical cocktails from the charming patio bar.
The Completa de Caballo Grande is a great way to experience all the famous fares here, as it includes Ropa Vieja, Lechon Asado, and Picadillo Habanero. For chowing down on craveable and authentic Cuban food, El Meson is one of the best restaurants in Key West and one of the best places to get some authentic Cuban cuisine in Key West!

El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar

Latitudes is a renowned fine dining restaurant of the area, known not only for its elevated cuisine but for its breathtaking vistas looking out over the Gulf of Mexico. It’s part of Sunset Key Cottages, serving up fresh and flavor-packed island eats.To get to Latitudes you have to take a ferry, but it’s easily the best place to watch the sunset in Key West. You’ll watch the sunset over the water while enjoying a mouthwatering meal. The menu is created with locally sourced ingredients based on what is in season and each plate feels like a work of art.

Key West for Foodies

Bookable Tours and Experiences - Key West

Need a hotel or flight? Search below:

Download The Tripographer app!